Contents:
Glamour, gratitude &
good times
Peter Shelley

On Saturday 13 September the Pittwater Offshore Men's Shed
(POSMS) held its black tie gala and offshore community
awards ceremony at the Waterfrond Café, Church Point. How
good was the feeling in the room as we came together to
celebrate the ‘unsung heroes’ of our community! It was an
absolute privilege for POSMS to facilitate this sold-out
gathering on behalf of our offshore community, and a
heartfelt thank you goes to everyone who joined us for
this special event.
|
Peter
Shelley, POSMS President
|
The award winners:
OFFSHORE COMMUNITY BUSINESS AWARD: Matt Lakeman Services
(Matt Lakeman)
COMMUNITY DRIVER OF THE YEAR AWARD: Billy Dwyer (community
vehicle driver)
COMMUNITY COMMUNICATOR OF THE YEAR: Roy Baker
NATURE NURTURER AWARD: Sharon Kinnison & Nick Ives
CREATIVE SPARK AWARD: Nettie Lodge
HELPING HAND AWARD: Carol Beth Floyd
OFFSHORE SOS AWARD: Ian White & Andrew Cutler
SPIRIT OF OFFSHORE LIFE AWARD: Cass Gye
Silent auction winners:
Louise Mahady (Sophie Lamb beauty hamper), Wayne Baxter
(Gwyn Perkins original artwork), Sharon Johnson
(Waterfront Cafe voucher), Julie Paterson (Creative
Hampers hamper), Cathy Shelley (Mike Hall original
pottery), Chris Canty (Scotland Island Lodge
accommodation), Julie Patterson (Allsail Sailing voucher);
Wayne Baxter (Ana Fellay design consult), Chris Canty
(Nettie Lodge original artwork), James Wish (Ocean Boats
guided fishing experience), Marie Minslow (Landcruising
Australia motor home hire), Rachel Philpotts (whale
watching experience on Stardust).
Thanks go to all who donated an auction prize.
Thanks also to all our helpers, sponsors, and
supporters.
Of course, any event is only as successful as the
collective efforts of the many people who get behind it.
On behalf of the POSMS committee, a huge thank you to the
following for helping to make this celebration possible:
Venue set-up (red carpet, lighting & band):
Josephine Carter-May, Meredith Rasdall, Cathy Shelley,
Mike Bookey, Richard Rasdall
|
POSMS
Committee (l to r):
Simon Tucker, Richard Rasdall, Peter
Shelley, Jon Ryan, Shane May
|
Gala Sponsors
Rash Media (Richard Rasdall), Landcruising Australia
(Harriet Witchell and Simon Tucker), Church Point Ferries
(Penny Glen), Waterfront Cafe (Mary Romeo), Ocean Boats
(Shane May), Scotland Island Lodge (Colin and Rosemary
Haskell), Eastern Wharf Pottery (Mike Hall), Meredith
Rasdall Visual Art (Meredith Rasdall), Sophie Lamb Beauty
Therapy (Sophie Blackband), Creative Hampers (Rachelle
Philpotts), Ana Fellay Designs (Ana Fellay), Oneill
Photographics (Natalie Page and Shane O’Neill), Jane and
Adrian Mathews, Gwyn Perkins, John Marshall and RMYC
Broken Bay.
POSMS supporters throughout the year
Johnson Bros Marine Services (Ben Johnson), Mick Miller
Enhancement Coach (Mick Miller), Dad & Dave Brewery,
SIRA (committee).
Thanks to Oneill Photographics, photos of the night can be
downloaded from here.
We’d love your feedback!
Let us know your views - what went well, what we could do
better (or differently) if we ran a similar event in the
future - all feedback welcome!
Some reflections on
winning ... and losing
Roy Baker

The community awards ceremony, organised by the Pittwater
Offshore Men’s Shed, went off like a banger, by all
accounts. I was in Europe at the time, but I hear it was a
tremendous success. Congratulations to all involved, many
of whom you’ll find named in the article above.
Also above you’ll find a list of the award winners. Spot
something? Yes, I am among them. I don’t think I’m
particularly noted for discouraging accolades, so let’s
get the self-celebration out of the way first. Did I feel
humbled and honoured to win an award? No. I was bloody
delighted. For the first time since Class 4A, Dudley
Grammar School, I’d won a prize.
But, for once, this article isn’t just about me, nor is it
about my fellow award recipients, nor those whose hard
work made the night a success. Yes, they are to be
congratulated and thanked. But here I write for all those
who didn’t win, more so for those who weren’t even
nominated. Can I pull this off without detracting from the
achievements of the organisers, or the very real
contributions of the winners and nominees? Well, I’m
Community Communicator of the Year, so let’s give it a
shot.
The benefits of awards are obvious. It’s essential that
community contributions are acknowledged, most of all my
own. No one should sacrifice without reward, and awards
can motivate and inspire. But whatever euphemisms we
choose, we are left dancing around some uncomfortable
words: competition, comparison, success, winner, and, I’m
afraid, failure and loser.
The very real danger is that the pleasure given to an
award recipient might come at the cost of disappointment
to others. Some who don't receive recognition might feel
inspired to give more; others might feel discouraged. Why
bother giving to our community when you don’t even get
nominated? The real question is how we let some soar
without taking the wind from another’s wings. Or, to put
it in the more prosaic language of economics, how do we
avoid this being a zero-sum game?
No one has contacted me expressing hurt. But it's not
impossible that someone somewhere feels at least a pang of
disappointment or envy, particularly if they feel they've
given to our community and not been adequately
acknowledged. If that's you, don’t worry — I’d have felt
the same. Where there’s hurt, let it be acknowledged. It’s
a very human response.
Much as community awards serve a purpose, and I'm sure
they do, it's worth remembering that none of us signed up
for this particular competition. It’s not like the island
running race—which I organise, incidentally. (That’s
something you might like to note for next year’s awards.)
With a running race, no one is obliged to enter, and if
you participate then you do so knowing that someone is
going to come first. If that isn't you, it's a bit
precious to get upset. But with these awards, you might
feel as though you were in a race you didn't ask to run.
Something else needs to be acknowledged. These awards
celebrated more than speed. Being able to run fast doesn't
make you a better person. But with some of these awards we
came closer to our core values, such as kindness and
generosity.
Speaking of feeling superior to others, I may have let
slip that I attended grammar school. In order to decide
who would attend that school, every child in town had to
sit an exam, which we were told would measure our
intelligence. No doubt the process was intended to nurture
talent, and sometimes it did. But I know some children
felt branded as losers. I 'passed' that exam and at the
time I felt proud to do so. But my father was a teacher
and he coached me for the test. Few had that advantage.
Dear reader, let me say it clearly: these offshore awards
did not measure your value as a human being, regardless of
whether you won, and regardless of whether you were
nominated. No one should feel reduced, in themselves or in
their unique contribution to our community. There are all
kinds of reasons why some people and acts are celebrated
more than others. Some people are better known, perhaps
because they are louder, have lived here longer, or are
better at reminding us of that fact. Some service is, by
nature, less visible, and some calls for discretion — not
everything can or should be announced on Facebook.
Every day in this community, someone is invited for
coffee, someone’s shopping is carried, litter is picked
up, a neighbour’s boat is checked on. The list is endless.
Some acts are noticed, others aren't. Some attract thanks
and others don’t. In life’s tombola, never underestimate
the element of luck.
As for my award, communication isn’t just about
newsletters. It’s in the smiles to neighbours, the praise
we offer a child, the social missteps forgiven, the warmth
of simple words and gestures. These everyday
communications bind us together more than anything I
publish.
All in all, we aren’t too bad a community. And we all play
our part in making it that way. After all, when it comes
to awards ceremonies, it’s like raffle tickets: some names
get drawn, others don’t. But that doesn’t make the cake
stall any less delicious.
Scotland Island Community
Hall
Saturday 25 October,
7 - 9 pm
To help defray
expenses, the Recreation Club ask for $5 per person
per attendance.
Community Hall,
Scotland Island
Sunday 26 October, 10 to 12
noon

Scotland Island
Community Hall
Sunday 26 October,
12 noon
|
A
scene from Wedding
Island
by Bogue Anthill, performed in the
Community Hall, May 2025
|
Following the success
of Wedding Island, performed on Scotland
Island in May 2025, a group of enthusiasts in
community theatre are now turning their minds to the
next offshore play. Written by Jasper
Marlow, A Devine Mystery is provisionally
scheduled for performances in May 2026.
We plan to meet
immediately after the island café in order to gauge
interest in the production and perhaps hold a script
reading. If you are interested in taking part,
either on or off stage, please let me know, with
your phone number, and I'll add you to the relevant
WhatsApp group.
Roy Baker
Missed out on a previous
newsletter?
To Contribute
Subscription Information
Scotland Island
Community Calendar
For further information on island events, click
here
The Online Local
Contacts Guide
SIRA Photo Archive

The
views expressed in this newsletter are not
necessarily those of the Scotland Island Residents
Association (SIRA),
or the Western Pittwater Community
Association (WPCA)
|