To: "John Hammell"
Subject: Nutrithérapie
Date: Sun, 29 Jun 2003 16:33:08 +0100
MIME-Version: 1.0
Content-Type: multipart/mixed;
boundary="----=_NextPart_000_000A_01C33E5C.1F6482E0"
X-Priority: 3
X-MSMail-Priority: Normal
X-Mailer: Microsoft Outlook Express 5.00.2615.200
X-MimeOLE: Produced By Microsoft MimeOLE V5.00.2615.200
See here below what the people in the French HFM and supplement industry have to say about the Hercberg toad (French and English):
Le Dr responsable est le Dr Serge Hercberg
Les dosages utilisés sont ridiculement faibles et correspondent aux ANC
Vit E - 12 mg en réalité il faudrait 260
Vit B1 - 1.5 mg 100
Vit B6 - 2.2 mg 100
Vit B12 - 3 micro grammes 100
Vit C - 80 mg 3000
Le tout synthétique of course...
Il faudra avoir beaucoup de chance pour que le Dr Hercberg ne s'en serve pas pour dénoncer l'inutilité des "méga doses" qui sont en fait les justes dosages physiologiques.
Les ANC visent à éviter les carences aiguës mais se moquent des niveaux qui confèrent une santé maximale.
----- Original Message -----
From: FORTERRE
To: Emma Holister
Sent: Friday, June 27, 2003 9:23 PM
Subject: Re: etude douteuse?
Emma,
The SUVIMAX study is that I can call a no value study.
It is driven by Dr HERCBERG, which is a man entirely related with agro alimentary firms. You can find the list of these firms on http://istna.melody.fr/sites/suvimax/ All these firms pay for the study, that is a demonstrarion that this study is industry dependant. Question is : Is Dr HERCBERG an independant researcher?
The amount of the five selected nutriments, Viamins E (30 mg) and C (150 mg), bétacaroten (6mg), Zn(20 mg) and Se (100 µg), are just above the ANC levels, that is far below values recognised as really protecting our immunity.
There is an important result to be confirmed: Selected French people do not eat the amount of nutriment as required in the French ARC (AQR). So, improvement due to supplement could have some visible results, but it is not a valuable demonstration.
A remark : the selection of the patients do not reflect the mean of the french poeple, as, for the placebo people, there are less cases of heart deasises and cancers as in the whole population ...
And the conclusion driven by HERCBERG, as proposed at TV yesterday : There is no need of supplements , a good nutrition is enough... What a lie! As it demonstrtes that french people cannot eat the nutriment amount proposed in the protocol.
The most dangerous point : this man successed in convincing the french officials that he must drive the french nutrition programs...
You can read the opnion of Thierry SOCCAR, his most contestative journalist, in www.lejournalsante.com/Nutriments/
For us, what a pity ! HERCBERG is not a "sous-marin", he is like a cancer.
Gérard FORTERRE
An other comment on SUVIMAX : do you imagine the amount of money, from the CNAM, and INSERM, which are governement paid, and from the supporting firms, money which is misused in the SUVIMAX study, as the results are all but new... but are "FRENCH". And the last communications from HERCBERG show that it now became an opposite to the all food supplements. He added also that food supplement are dangerous, whitout any demonstration...Due to his new responsibilites, he can very often delivers this message to the news.
So is a cancer ...
Have a nice reading of the Bill SARDY book.
Gérard FORTERRE
Sorry, I make a mistake onhis family name;, SARDI,
You will find his website at the end of his book : www.askbillsardi.com
Please, read this book, I think it can be a good way to contest the collapsing official medcine and its wrong support, the pharmacochimic trusts, if we generalise suchan approach.
Gérard FORTERRE
International Advocates for Health Freedom
POB 10632 Blacksburg VA 24062 USA
http://www.iahf.com; http://iadsa-exposed.tripod.com
800-333-2553 N.America
540-961-0476 World
 | Powered by YMLP.com | |
| | ||